Best Restaurants Near the Museum of Natural History

After marveling at mammoths, meteorites, and massive dinosaurs, it’s only natural to feel a little hungry. Luckily, the American Museum of Natural History is surrounded by fantastic places to eat — whether you're in the mood for an elegant sit-down dinner, a family-friendly lunch, or something quick between exhibits. The Upper West Side offers everything from New York classics to cozy cafés and upscale global flavors, all within walking distance of the museum. Whether you're traveling with kids, solo, or as a couple, we’ve rounded up 15 of the best restaurants near the Museum of Natural History — sorted by splurge level and guaranteed to satisfy. 

High-End 

Nice Matin 

• Walking distance: 6 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 79th St (1) 

• Cuisine: French-Mediterranean 

• Google rating: 4.4 

Nice Matin brings sun-soaked Provençal charm to the Upper West Side with its airy dining room and sidewalk café seating. The menu draws inspiration from the south of France, with dishes like bouillabaisse, steak frites, and herb-crusted lamb chops. Brunch is a neighborhood favorite, featuring fluffy omelets, French toast, and expertly pulled espresso. At dinner, the vibe shifts from café to candlelit bistro, making it ideal for date night or relaxed celebrations. The wine list skews French and thoughtfully curated, with bottles and glasses to suit any mood. 

The Milling Room 

• Walking distance: 5 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 81st St–Museum of Natural History (B, C) 

• Cuisine: New American 

• Google rating: 4.5 

The Milling Room feels like a secret grand hall tucked into the Upper West Side — think dramatic high ceilings, a buzzing central bar, and moody lighting that sets the tone for a refined night out. The menu leans into seasonal New American fare with standout dishes like duck breast with farro, braised short ribs, and grilled oysters. They also have solid vegetarian options and an excellent cocktail program. 

Celeste 

• Walking distance: 8 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 81st St–Museum of Natural History (B, C) 

• Cuisine: Italian 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Celeste is the definition of a hidden gem. This cash-only Italian trattoria keeps a low profile, but locals know it’s one of the best spots for rustic, home-style cooking on the Upper West Side. The atmosphere is warm and bustling — it’s not white-tablecloth fancy, but the food easily competes with higher-end Italian joints in the city. Menu highlights include rich porcini ravioli, veal saltimbocca, and daily rotating specials like squid ink linguine or braised rabbit. The wine list is short but high-quality, and prices are surprisingly reasonable for the quality.  

Mid-Range 

Jacob’s Pickles 

• Walking distance: 8 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 86th St (1, B, C) 

• Cuisine: Southern comfort food 

• Google rating: 4.6 

Jacob’s Pickles is a Southern-style haven on the Upper West Side, famous for its bold comfort food and ultra-generous portions. The fried chicken is legendary — crispy, juicy, and stacked sky-high on flaky buttermilk biscuits with honey or hot sauce. The mac and cheese is gooey, the pickles are house-made and addictive, and the beer list is impressively curated with local and Southern brews. The vibe? Lively, rustic, and always buzzing. Inside, you’ll find exposed brick, dark wood, and a warm, welcoming staff. It’s great for families, groups, or anyone who’s worked up a serious appetite exploring dinosaurs and dioramas. Portions are hefty, but you’ll be dreaming about leftovers. 

The Mermaid Inn – Upper West Side 

• Walking distance: 9 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 81st St–Museum of Natural History (B, C) 

• Cuisine: Seafood 

• Google rating: 4.5 

The Mermaid Inn offers a breezy escape from the city with its fresh seafood and beachy-chic interiors. Think white tile, nautical decor, and candlelit coziness — it’s a great spot for a casual but grown-up lunch or dinner. Oysters are a must (especially during happy hour), and the lobster roll is one of the best in the city: buttery, packed with claw meat, and served with Old Bay fries. Fish tacos, clam chowder, and a simple grilled branzino round out the crowd-pleasers. The wine and cocktail list is equally thoughtful — refreshing, crisp, and seafood-friendly. 

Café Luxembourg 

• Walking distance: 5 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 81st St–Museum of Natural History (B, C) 

• Cuisine: French-American 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Café Luxembourg is a quintessential Upper West Side bistro — stylish, cozy, and effortlessly classic. With its red banquettes, white tablecloths, and Paris-meets-NYC energy, this spot is beloved by locals, celebs, and anyone who appreciates timeless charm. The menu leans French-American with reliably excellent fare: steak frites, moules marinières, roast chicken, and a buttery croque monsieur. The cocktails are strong and stirred just right, and the brunch here is a neighborhood ritual. Though upscale in feel, it’s not out-of-reach price-wise — especially for the quality. 

Leyla 

• Walking distance: 10 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 86th St (1, B, C) 

• Cuisine: Turkish/Mediterranean 

• Google rating: 4.6 

Leyla is a tucked-away Turkish gem offering flavorful Mediterranean fare in a gorgeous, greenery-filled townhouse. The interior is cozy and elegant — think deep teal walls, woven lanterns, and a warm, welcoming vibe. Start with creamy hummus, crispy lamb rolls, or their house-baked bread with za’atar oil. For mains, try the manti (Turkish dumplings), roasted branzino, or the tender lamb shank — all seasoned to perfection. Vegetarian options are plentiful, and the cocktail list is full of Eastern Mediterranean infusions that feel both creative and refreshing. 

Budget-Friendly 

Shake Shack – Columbus Avenue 

• Walking distance: 4 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 81st St–Museum of Natural History (B, C) 

• Cuisine: American (Burgers) 

• Google rating: 4.4 

Shake Shack is a reliable crowd-pleaser just a few steps from the museum. Their ShackBurger is juicy and perfectly seasoned, the crinkle-cut fries are golden and crisp, and the shakes live up to their name. Vegetarians can opt for the mushroom-filled 'Shroom Burger, and there’s a solid chicken sandwich if beef’s not your thing. The interior is bright and bustling, with both indoor seating and an outdoor patio if the weather’s on your side. Lines can stretch at peak times, but service moves fast and the quality stays consistent. 

Gray’s Papaya 

• Walking distance: 6 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 72nd St (1, 2, 3) 

• Cuisine: Hot dogs 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Gray’s Papaya is a New York institution — open late, famous for its recession-proof prices, and home to some of the best hot dogs in town. The “Recession Special” (two franks and a tropical drink) is an unbeatable deal, and the papaya drink itself is as iconic as the signage. Dogs come griddled with that perfect snap and can be loaded with onions, sauerkraut, mustard, and relish. This spot is walk-up counter only, no seating, no frills — just fast, tasty street food that’s stood the test of time. Whether you’re on a budget or just want to eat like a true New Yorker, Gray’s is a cultural and culinary must. 

Joe Coffee Company – 73rd Street 

• Walking distance: 7 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 72nd St (1, 2, 3) 

• Cuisine: Coffee & light bites 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Joe Coffee serves some of the best coffee on the Upper West Side, just a short stroll from the museum. Their espresso is rich and smooth, and the pastries — sourced from local bakeries — are always fresh and flavorful. You’ll find croissants, banana bread, breakfast sandwiches, and yogurt parfaits — perfect if you’re on the go or just need a little something to get you through the next exhibit. 

16 Handles – UWS 

• Walking distance: 4 minutes 

• Nearest subway: 81st St–Museum of Natural History (B, C) 

• Cuisine: Frozen yogurt 

• Google rating: 4.5 

16 Handles is a fun, choose-your-own-adventure frozen yogurt shop just around the corner from AMNH — perfect for kids, families, or anyone needing a sweet cooldown after a museum marathon. You can pick from a rotating selection of self-serve flavors (from tart to chocolatey to plant-based), then go wild at the toppings bar — sprinkles, cookie crumbles, mochi, sauces, you name it. The vibe is cheerful and casual, and the seating area is bright and clean. You pay by weight, so it’s budget-friendly if you keep things light, or a full-on dessert party if you're feeling celebratory. 

For more, make the most of your night in NYC, and don’t miss the best historical spots in the city.  

Step up your sightseeing with Go City®. 

We make it easy to explore the best a city has to offer. We’re talking top attractions, hidden gems and local tours, all for one low price. Plus you'll enjoy guaranteed savings, compared to buying individual attraction tickets. 

See more, do more, and experience more with Go City® – just choose a pass to get started!