Best Restaurants Near Luna Park Coney Island

Your go-to guide for eating well near Luna Park.

Published: April 17, 2025
Best Restaurants Near Luna Park Coney Island

Whether you’re fresh off a roller coaster or just finished strolling the boardwalk, one thing’s for sure: Luna Park works up an appetite. Luckily, the surrounding area has you covered — think sizzling slices, waterfront seafood, and old-school diners with milkshakes to match. From historic pizza joints to sit-down spots with ocean views, Coney Island's dining scene is every bit as fun as the amusement park itself. We've rounded up the 15 best restaurants near Luna Park — broken down by budget. 

 

High-End 

Gargiulo’s Italian Restaurant 

  • Walking distance: 5 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Italian-American 

  • Google rating: 4.5 

Gargiulo’s has been a Coney Island classic since 1907, and stepping inside feels like entering another era — in the best way. With its chandeliers, high ceilings, and white-linen tables, this historic spot offers old-school Italian dining just steps from Luna Park. The menu is a love letter to Italian-American comfort food: veal parmigiana, seafood linguine, baked clams, and house-made pastas in rich, flavorful sauces. Everything’s generously portioned, served with flair, and backed by warm, attentive service. It’s perfect for a celebratory dinner after a day of thrill rides or a long beach stroll. Bonus: the wine list is extensive, and there’s plenty of space for big groups or family get-togethers. 

 

Tatiana Restaurant 

  • Walking distance: 6 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Russian / Eastern European 

  • Google rating: 4.4 

Tatiana Restaurant is equal parts dinner and show — a lively beachfront dining experience with strong Russian and Eastern European roots. Located right on the boardwalk, Tatiana offers sea views, glitzy interiors, and on weekends, live music or dance performances that turn dinner into an event. The food? Generous, flavorful, and delightfully off the beaten path. Standouts include beef stroganoff, blini with caviar, Georgian-style khachapuri, and mixed grill platters that arrive sizzling. Portions are made for sharing, and vodka flows freely. 

 

Liman Restaurant 

  • Walking distance: 8 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Turkish / Mediterranean (Seafood) 

  • Google rating: 4.6 

Liman Restaurant is a serene, seafood-forward spot that feels like a Mediterranean retreat right in the heart of Brooklyn. Located along Emmons Avenue, it’s just far enough from the buzz of the boardwalk to feel like a peaceful escape. The menu features ultra-fresh fish grilled to perfection, creamy hummus, smoky eggplant dips, and hearty mains like lamb shish kebab or shrimp casserole. The décor is warm and contemporary, and outdoor seating offers breezy views of the water. 

Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano 

Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano 

  • Walking distance: 10 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Italian (Pizza) 

  • Google rating: 4.6 

Totonno’s is as legendary as they come — serving coal-fired pies since 1924. The menu is simple: pizza. But what a pizza it is. With a crispy charred crust, tangy sauce, and bubbling mozzarella, each pie is handmade and utterly unforgettable. There’s no pepperoni mountain or trendy toppings here — just top-tier ingredients and century-old technique. The space is no-frills and cash-only, but the line out the door speaks volumes. Many consider it one of NYC’s best pizzas, and we’re inclined to agree. 

Tom’s Coney Island 

  • Walking distance: 4 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: American (Diner) 

  • Google rating: 4.5 

Tom’s Coney Island isn’t your average diner — it’s a sun-soaked, retro-style oasis right on the boardwalk. Open all day, it’s as perfect for pancakes and coffee as it is for burgers and beer. Inside, you’ll find vintage signs, cheerful colors, and a friendly staff that makes everyone feel like a regular. Menu favorites include fluffy omelets, stacked burgers, thick-cut fries, and their beloved cinnamon walnut pancakes. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the view of the ocean doesn’t hurt either.  

 

Mid-Range 

Nathan’s Famous (Original Location) 

  • Walking distance: 2 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: American (Hot Dogs & Fries) 

  • Google rating: 4.4 

The original Nathan’s Famous is more than a hot dog stand — it’s a New York City institution. Open since 1916, this boardwalk-side staple is the spiritual home of the Fourth of July hot dog eating contest and still slings legendary dogs with that perfect snap. Order them plain, with kraut, chili, or cheese — or mix it up with crinkle-cut fries, corn dogs, or a lobster roll. It’s fast, nostalgic, and loaded with that Coney Island energy. The seating is outdoor and casual, and the line moves fast even on busy weekends. 

Paul’s Daughter 

  • Walking distance: 4 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: American (Seafood / Beach Fare) 

  • Google rating: 4.5 

Paul’s Daughter has been serving classic boardwalk eats since the 1960s — and it still feels like the heart of Coney Island. Located right on the boardwalk, it’s the kind of place where you grab a draft beer and a clam roll while watching the waves roll in. The menu features fried seafood baskets, Italian sausages, grilled corn, and a top-tier lobster roll. The setting is relaxed, nostalgic, and colorful — with those iconic giant figurines on the roof and beach views from every angle. 

Boardwalk Pizzeria 

Boardwalk Pizzeria 

  • Walking distance: 2 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Italian (Pizza) 

  • Google rating: 4.4 

Boardwalk Pizzeria is exactly what you want after a ride on the Cyclone: a thin, cheesy, foldable New York slice, hot out of the oven. It’s quick, it’s satisfying, and it’s right where you need it — nestled on the boardwalk, mere steps from Luna Park. Choose from classic cheese, pepperoni, sausage, or white pie, or try their square Sicilian slices for something thicker. Prices are reasonable, the staff is friendly, and the pizza hits the spot every single time. Grab a slice to go or snag a table outside and soak up the beach buzz. 

Wheelhouse NYC 

  • Walking distance: 6 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: American (Burgers & Sandwiches) 

  • Google rating: 4.6 

Wheelhouse NYC is a modern burger and sandwich joint with a fun, surf-style aesthetic and a great reputation for quality eats. Their signature burger — topped with bacon, cheddar, and a tangy house sauce — is a standout, but the fried chicken sandwich, loaded grilled cheese, and veggie options are equally tempting. Add crispy fries, onion rings, or a milkshake (or beer), and you’ve got a satisfying meal in a laid-back setting. The space is cool and casual, with indoor and outdoor seating and a chill soundtrack that complements the boardwalk vibe. 

Dona Zita 

  • Walking distance: 2 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Mexican 

  • Google rating: 4.5 

Dona Zita might just be Coney Island’s best-kept secret — a humble walk-up taco stand slinging some of the tastiest Mexican food in the borough. Their grilled steak tacos, chicken burritos, and cheesy quesadillas are fresh, flavorful, and packed with personality. You’ll also find elote (Mexican street corn), tamales, and house-made aguas frescas to round out your feast. There’s shaded outdoor seating, quick service, and unbeatable value for the portion sizes.  

Budget-Friendly 

Williams Candy 

  • Walking distance: 2 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Desserts / Sweets 

  • Google rating: 4.6 

Williams Candy is a vintage sweet shop just a stone’s throw from Luna Park, and it’s pure sugar-coated nostalgia. Known for its bright red candy apples, hand-dipped chocolate treats, and fluffy cotton candy, this spot has been serving classic boardwalk treats for decades. Everything is made in-house, from the caramel to the chocolate-covered marshmallows, and the smell alone will draw you in. There’s no seating — this is a grab-and-go situation — but it’s perfect for snacking while strolling the boardwalk. It’s also a must-visit if you're with kids or just want to satisfy your sweet tooth with something old-school. For a taste of carnival magic that costs just a few bucks, Williams Candy is a joyful stop. 

 

Pete’s Clam Stop 

Pete’s Clam Stop 

  • Walking distance: 4 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Seafood / Street Food 

  • Google rating: 4.4 

Pete’s Clam Stop is a classic Coney Island walk-up seafood shack, serving up fried clam strips, shrimp baskets, fish sandwiches, and cold drinks with no fuss, no frills, and lots of flavor. You’ll find it just off Surf Avenue, and while it might not look like much, it delivers on that old-school beach-town seafood fix. Everything is made to order, served hot and crispy, and portioned generously. There are picnic tables out front and the atmosphere is delightfully casual. 

Footprints Café Express 

  • Walking distance: 10 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Caribbean 

  • Google rating: 4.4 

A mini version of the popular Brooklyn Caribbean chain, Footprints Express brings bold island flavor to Coney Island. The jerk chicken wraps are a standout — smoky, spicy, and packed with juicy meat — and their rasta pasta (creamy, spicy penne with veggies and chicken or shrimp) has a serious fanbase. The vibe is grab-and-go, but the portions are generous and the flavors are fire. Expect reggae beats, friendly counter service, and food that warms your soul and fills you up. 

Rita’s Italian Ice 

  • Walking distance: 2 minutes 

  • Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

  • Cuisine: Frozen Desserts 

  • Google rating: 4.5 

Rita’s Italian Ice is a sweet way to cool down after a day in the sun. This colorful stand offers smooth, fruity ices in rotating flavors like mango, cotton candy, and Swedish Fish (yes, really), plus soft serve, frozen custard, and gelati combos. It’s fast, refreshing, and perfect for kids or anyone looking to beat the heat. There’s usually a line on hot days, but it moves quickly and the staff are speedy and friendly. 

For more, check out our comprehensive 4-day NYC itinerary, and check out some of the best views of the city. 

Step up your sightseeing with Go City®. 

We make it easy to explore the best a city has to offer. We’re talking top attractions, hidden gems and local tours, all for one low price. Plus you'll enjoy guaranteed savings, compared to buying individual attraction tickets. 

See more, do more, and experience more with Go City® – just choose a pass to get started! 

 

Powered by AI

This article was generated with the help of AI to provide accurate and up-to-date information. The Go City team has reviewed and curated the content to ensure it meets our quality standards for accuracy and relevance.

Continue reading

Blog

Quirky Things to do in New York   

What can we say? We love New York! With a long list of cultural amenities, interesting historical sites, and exciting events, we couldn't think of a better place to visit for a one-of-a-kind vacation. Whether you’re looking for unusual museums and attractions, or ideas for fun activities like kayaking on the East River, we’ve got you covered. So, if you’re planning to make the visit, take a look at our list for some of the best unusual things to do in the city. We hope you love them as much as we do. Explore the City The urban landscape displays some of the most creative and provocative street art in the city. Those looking for something a little different from the usual gallery experience might appreciate a tour of the Bushwick area, which is known as a mecca for American and International artists alike. Along the route, you’ll be able to view popular Blek Le Rat stencils and Shepard Fairey murals as well as some inspiring pieces by some lesser-known artists. In addition, your tour guide will take you through the history of the New York graffiti movement and explain more about the various styles of artistry that developed in the area. If skyscrapers aren’t quite your thing, why not check out St. Patrick’s Basilica? A total must for architecture lovers and history buffs, this Neo-Gothic style Catholic cathedral offers a refreshing change from the ultra-modern cityscape. Visitors can take tours to appreciate and admire the beauty of this historic visual landmark and learn more about its background. Still, the real star of the show is the catacombs tour, permitting visitors to explore the awe-inspiring tunnels running beneath the city center. For curious adventurers only, we recommend a trip on the Staten Island Ferry. An undoubtedly major attraction and mainstay of New York City culture, the ferry grants stunning views of Ellis Island, the Statue of Liberty, and Lower Manhattan Skyline. We suggest putting a day aside to explore all that the island has to offer. Check out the South Beach Boardwalk, have a picnic at Silver Lake Park, or visit Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden – the choice is yours! Get Cultured Another one of our favorite unique attractions to see in the city is the New York Transit Museum. Built into an authentic subway station in downtown Brooklyn, the institute celebrates the fascinating history of the region’s public transportation network. The museum’s remarkable collection features everything from construction equipment and vintage subway cars to old photographs and tickets. Enthralling and enjoyable, the museum provides the perfect educational experience for those of all ages. Looking for a unique and artsy museum to pique your interest? Well, look no further. Located on Madison Avenue, The Morgan Library houses one of the largest on-paper collections in the United States. The perfect stop for bibliophiles and creative types alike, the library features a broad collection of art, books and historic documents that will keep you dazzled for hours. Highlights include Mozart’s handwritten score of the Haffner Symphony, Henry David Thoreau’s Walden, and the only remaining manuscript of Milton’s Paradise Lost. The experience of viewing these influential works up close is entirely unforgettable – don't skip it! Why see a museum when you could see a quirky museum instead? Just across the East River, the Queens Museum seeks to collect, exhibit and interpret global contemporary art for a wide audience. The institute’s main draw is its room-sized scale model of the five boroughs, which is continuously updated. Still, that isn’t to say that its other pieces aren’t well worth the visit – between their permanent collection of Louis Comfort Tiffany stained glass, huge map of the city water supply system, and collection of artifacts from the 1964 and 1964 World Fairs, there’s a lot to see here. Find Fun Activities One of the best alternative activities in the city has got to be kayaking on the East River. Yep, you read that right. The city’s coastal waterways serve as a unique urban paddling destination – and with good reason. This energetic and outdoorsy activity grants stunning views of the midtown skyline. If you’ve never kayaked before, there’s no need to worry – you’ll be guided by a professional team and provided with the right equipment to ensure total safety. All you have to do is show up with and a positive attitude and readiness to explore! Those who are travelling with family might want to check out the next item on our list. Situated in Lower Manhattan, the Museum of Ice Cream offers a fun and unique experience based upon our favorite frozen delight. Bring your sweetest dreams to life through a number of multisensory installations and imaginative concepts. Fan favorites include the 3-storey indoor Ice Cream Portal, the Rainbow Tunnel, and the Sprinkle Pool. Don’t forget to bring your phone to capture the colorful and whimsical exhibits up close. The city is filled with hidden gems – you just need to know where to look. Tucked away in the Lower East Side, the Chinatown Fair Family Fun Center offers an entertainment experience to remember. This historic video arcade presents a wide array of classic and newer games, with a particular focus on competitive fighting. With its vibrant atmosphere, underground vibe, and unique draw, this spot is perfect for hanging out with friends and family after a long day of exploring. If you’re looking for a bit of fun, this is where you want to be. The state of New York never ceases to amaze us with its fun and quirky attractions. The city is like a spectacular buffet of cultural experiences. From one-of-a-kind daytrips to interesting museums and tours, the area has plenty to offer those looking for a little something outside of the box. Those who visit seeking diversity, vibrancy and eccentricity won’t be disappointed. To make the best out of your vacation, check out Go City’s All-Inclusive Pass and Explorer Pass. For more information, connect with us on Instagram and Facebook.
Sarah Harris
Brooklyn Bridge
Blog

I went back to the Big Apple 30 years later – here's how I saw more and spent less

We caught up with John Fernandez to find out how he used our very own Explorer Pass to plan a nostalgic vacation to NYC.
Selina Whitby
memorial day, USA flag in front of New York
Blog

14+ Fun Things to Do This Memorial Day Weekend in NYC

Memorial Day weekend is the perfect opportunity to visit New York's world-class museums and historical sites, then round it all off with epic holiday fireworks and a picnic in the park.
Katie Sagal

Have a 5% discount, on us!

Sign up to our newsletter and receive exclusive discounts, trip inspiration and attraction updates straight to your inbox.