Best Restaurants Near Luna Park Coney Island

Whether you’re fresh off a roller coaster or just finished strolling the boardwalk, one thing’s for sure: Luna Park works up an appetite. Luckily, the surrounding area has you covered — think sizzling slices, waterfront seafood, and old-school diners with milkshakes to match. From historic pizza joints to sit-down spots with ocean views, Coney Island's dining scene is every bit as fun as the amusement park itself. We've rounded up the 15 best restaurants near Luna Park — broken down by budget. 

High-End 

Gargiulo’s Italian Restaurant 

• Walking distance: 5 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Italian-American 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Gargiulo’s has been a Coney Island classic since 1907, and stepping inside feels like entering another era — in the best way. With its chandeliers, high ceilings, and white-linen tables, this historic spot offers old-school Italian dining just steps from Luna Park. The menu is a love letter to Italian-American comfort food: veal parmigiana, seafood linguine, baked clams, and house-made pastas in rich, flavorful sauces. Everything’s generously portioned, served with flair, and backed by warm, attentive service. It’s perfect for a celebratory dinner after a day of thrill rides or a long beach stroll. Bonus: the wine list is extensive, and there’s plenty of space for big groups or family get-togethers. 

Tatiana Restaurant 

• Walking distance: 6 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Russian / Eastern European 

• Google rating: 4.4 

Tatiana Restaurant is equal parts dinner and show — a lively beachfront dining experience with strong Russian and Eastern European roots. Located right on the boardwalk, Tatiana offers sea views, glitzy interiors, and on weekends, live music or dance performances that turn dinner into an event. The food? Generous, flavorful, and delightfully off the beaten path. Standouts include beef stroganoff, blini with caviar, Georgian-style khachapuri, and mixed grill platters that arrive sizzling. Portions are made for sharing, and vodka flows freely. 

Liman Restaurant 

• Walking distance: 8 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Turkish / Mediterranean (Seafood) 

• Google rating: 4.6 

Liman Restaurant is a serene, seafood-forward spot that feels like a Mediterranean retreat right in the heart of Brooklyn. Located along Emmons Avenue, it’s just far enough from the buzz of the boardwalk to feel like a peaceful escape. The menu features ultra-fresh fish grilled to perfection, creamy hummus, smoky eggplant dips, and hearty mains like lamb shish kebab or shrimp casserole. The décor is warm and contemporary, and outdoor seating offers breezy views of the water. 

Tom’s Coney Island 

• Walking distance: 4 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: American (Diner) 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Tom’s Coney Island isn’t your average diner — it’s a sun-soaked, retro-style oasis right on the boardwalk. Open all day, it’s as perfect for pancakes and coffee as it is for burgers and beer. Inside, you’ll find vintage signs, cheerful colors, and a friendly staff that makes everyone feel like a regular. Menu favorites include fluffy omelets, stacked burgers, thick-cut fries, and their beloved cinnamon walnut pancakes. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the view of the ocean doesn’t hurt either.  

Mid-Range 

Nathan’s Famous (Original Location) 

• Walking distance: 2 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: American (Hot Dogs & Fries) 

• Google rating: 4.4 

The original Nathan’s Famous is more than a hot dog stand — it’s a New York City institution. Open since 1916, this boardwalk-side staple is the spiritual home of the Fourth of July hot dog eating contest and still slings legendary dogs with that perfect snap. Order them plain, with kraut, chili, or cheese — or mix it up with crinkle-cut fries, corn dogs, or a lobster roll. It’s fast, nostalgic, and loaded with that Coney Island energy. The seating is outdoor and casual, and the line moves fast even on busy weekends. 

Paul’s Daughter 

• Walking distance: 4 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: American (Seafood / Beach Fare) 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Paul’s Daughter has been serving classic boardwalk eats since the 1960s — and it still feels like the heart of Coney Island. Located right on the boardwalk, it’s the kind of place where you grab a draft beer and a clam roll while watching the waves roll in. The menu features fried seafood baskets, Italian sausages, grilled corn, and a top-tier lobster roll. The setting is relaxed, nostalgic, and colorful — with those iconic giant figurines on the roof and beach views from every angle. 

Wheelhouse NYC 

• Walking distance: 6 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: American (Burgers & Sandwiches) 

• Google rating: 4.6 

Wheelhouse NYC is a modern burger and sandwich joint with a fun, surf-style aesthetic and a great reputation for quality eats. Their signature burger — topped with bacon, cheddar, and a tangy house sauce — is a standout, but the fried chicken sandwich, loaded grilled cheese, and veggie options are equally tempting. Add crispy fries, onion rings, or a milkshake (or beer), and you’ve got a satisfying meal in a laid-back setting. The space is cool and casual, with indoor and outdoor seating and a chill soundtrack that complements the boardwalk vibe. 

Dona Zita 

• Walking distance: 2 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Mexican 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Dona Zita might just be Coney Island’s best-kept secret — a humble walk-up taco stand slinging some of the tastiest Mexican food in the borough. Their grilled steak tacos, chicken burritos, and cheesy quesadillas are fresh, flavorful, and packed with personality. You’ll also find elote (Mexican street corn), tamales, and house-made aguas frescas to round out your feast. There’s shaded outdoor seating, quick service, and unbeatable value for the portion sizes.  

Budget-Friendly 

Williams Candy 

• Walking distance: 2 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Desserts / Sweets 

• Google rating: 4.6 

Williams Candy is a vintage sweet shop just a stone’s throw from Luna Park, and it’s pure sugar-coated nostalgia. Known for its bright red candy apples, hand-dipped chocolate treats, and fluffy cotton candy, this spot has been serving classic boardwalk treats for decades. Everything is made in-house, from the caramel to the chocolate-covered marshmallows, and the smell alone will draw you in. There’s no seating — this is a grab-and-go situation — but it’s perfect for snacking while strolling the boardwalk. It’s also a must-visit if you're with kids or just want to satisfy your sweet tooth with something old-school. For a taste of carnival magic that costs just a few bucks, Williams Candy is a joyful stop. 

Footprints Café Express 

• Walking distance: 10 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Caribbean 

• Google rating: 4.4 

A mini version of the popular Brooklyn Caribbean chain, Footprints Express brings bold island flavor to Coney Island. The jerk chicken wraps are a standout — smoky, spicy, and packed with juicy meat — and their rasta pasta (creamy, spicy penne with veggies and chicken or shrimp) has a serious fanbase. The vibe is grab-and-go, but the portions are generous and the flavors are fire. Expect reggae beats, friendly counter service, and food that warms your soul and fills you up. 

Rita’s Italian Ice 

• Walking distance: 2 minutes 

• Nearest subway: Coney Island–Stillwell Ave (D, F, N, Q) 

• Cuisine: Frozen Desserts 

• Google rating: 4.5 

Rita’s Italian Ice is a sweet way to cool down after a day in the sun. This colorful stand offers smooth, fruity ices in rotating flavors like mango, cotton candy, and Swedish Fish (yes, really), plus soft serve, frozen custard, and gelati combos. It’s fast, refreshing, and perfect for kids or anyone looking to beat the heat. There’s usually a line on hot days, but it moves quickly and the staff are speedy and friendly. 

For more, check out our comprehensive 4-day NYC itinerary, and check out some of the best views of the city. 

Step up your sightseeing with Go City®. 

We make it easy to explore the best a city has to offer. We’re talking top attractions, hidden gems and local tours, all for one low price. Plus you'll enjoy guaranteed savings, compared to buying individual attraction tickets. 

See more, do more, and experience more with Go City® – just choose a pass to get started!