New York City isn’t just about flashy shows and food carts—it’s also one of the best places in the world to dive into rich, layered history. If you’re looking to swap the crowds for a few thought-provoking hours, two standout museums near Central Park offer just that: the New-York Historical Society and The Jewish Museum. Both are filled with art, artifacts, and stories that span centuries—but they take different approaches to telling them. Whether you're into immersive exhibitions, cultural identity, or just want to see something new, here’s how these two museums stack up.
The Lowdown
New-York Historical Society Museum
-
Oldest museum in New York, founded in 1804
-
Features American history exhibits, presidential artifacts, and rotating shows
-
Home to the Center for Women’s History
-
Includes the DiMenna Children’s History Museum
-
Café and bookstore on-site
-
Located on Central Park West
The Jewish Museum
-
Located in a historic Fifth Avenue mansion
-
Focuses on Jewish culture, identity, and global history
-
Extensive collection of art, Judaica, and contemporary installations
-
Offers free admission on Saturdays
-
Excellent for art lovers and culture seekers
-
Located on the Museum Mile
Sounds Good, Tell Me More...
New-York Historical Society Museum
This museum is a classic in all the right ways. Just off Central Park West, the New-York Historical Society covers everything from colonial New York and Civil War history to suffragette movements and LGBTQ+ milestones. The exhibitions are rich in storytelling and often spotlight voices you won’t hear elsewhere. It’s also home to the DiMenna Children’s History Museum, a cleverly curated space with interactive exhibits designed to engage younger minds. Add to that the Center for Women’s History and regularly updated displays on U.S. presidents, and you've got a space that manages to feel scholarly without ever being stuffy.
The Jewish Museum
The Jewish Museum
If the New-York Historical Society leans into Americana, The Jewish Museum zooms in on cultural identity through the lens of Jewish history. Housed in the former Warburg Mansion, it’s a striking building filled with even more striking exhibits. Inside, you’ll find ancient ritual objects, modern art, and installations that speak to resilience, community, and expression. The museum balances history with contemporary art, often featuring work from Jewish and non-Jewish artists alike to explore universal themes. It’s intimate, insightful, and surprisingly emotional at times—ideal for travelers who want their museum experience to linger in their thoughts long after they leave.
Okay, So Which One Is Most Impressive?
The New York Historical Society scores major points for scope—it covers a broad swath of American history while tying in New York–specific stories. It's well-curated and consistently engaging. But The Jewish Museum shines with emotional impact and depth, especially when you’re in the mood for something more reflective. Both impress, just in different registers.
Which One Is More Fun?
If you're bringing kids or like to get hands-on with interactive displays, the New York Historical Society edges ahead. Its children’s museum section, thoughtful layout, and multimedia elements add a bit of playfulness. The Jewish Museum is quieter and more contemplative—not “fun” in the typical sense, but deeply rewarding if you enjoy thoughtful exploration and powerful art.
Which Is More Beautiful?
The Jewish Museum wins for architecture. Its Fifth Avenue mansion home features dramatic staircases, rich wood interiors, and stained-glass details. The exhibitions also lean toward the visually striking, mixing old-world beauty with modern minimalism. The New-York Historical Society has classic museum charm, but it’s the Jewish Museum that’ll have you snapping photos in between exhibits.
Which Has The Better View?
Which Has The Better View?
While neither museum offers skyline views, their settings shine in different ways. The New-York Historical Society faces Central Park West, so you’re steps away from leafy strolls and iconic sights. The Jewish Museum is on Museum Mile, flanked by historic buildings and close to Fifth Avenue views of the park. Choose between charming Upper West Side calm or glamorous Upper East Side grandeur.
How Do I Get There?
New-York Historical Society Museum
-
Address: 170 Central Park West at 77th Street
-
Subway: Take the B or C train to 81st Street – Museum of Natural History
The Jewish Museum
-
Address: 1109 Fifth Avenue at 92nd Street
-
Subway: Take the 4, 5, or 6 to 86th Street and walk west to Fifth Avenue
Both are easily walkable from Central Park and near other great museum stops.
Best Choice For Families, Couples, Or Friends
For families, the New York Historical Society is a win, thanks to its dedicated children’s museum and kid-friendly approach. Couples looking for something a bit artsier or more intimate might prefer The Jewish Museum. Friends? Either is a great choice depending on what you're into—history buffs will love the NYHS, while creative types may gravitate toward the Jewish Museum’s art-driven exhibitions.
I’ve Got Fidgety Kids To Entertain – Which Has More ‘Hands-On’ Activities?
Definitely the New York Historical Society. The DiMenna Children’s History Museum is packed with engaging exhibits and storytelling stations designed specifically for younger visitors. The Jewish Museum is more about quiet observation, so best to save that one for a grown-up outing.
What’s The Accessibility Like?
What’s The Accessibility Like?
Both museums are fully wheelchair accessible and provide accommodations for visitors with mobility, visual, or hearing impairments. The Jewish Museum also offers large-print materials and assistive listening devices. Staff at both institutions are helpful and well-trained in accessibility support.
Best Lunch Spots Nearby?
Near New York Historical Society
-
Café at the NYHS – Cozy café on-site serving sandwiches, soups, and pastries.
-
Shake Shack (Columbus Ave) – Casual crowd-pleaser with great burgers and fries.
-
Jacobs Pickles – Southern comfort food with a twist. The fried chicken and biscuit sandwiches are crowd favorites.
-
The Milling Room – Slightly upscale and atmospheric, great for a relaxed sit-down meal.
Near The Jewish Museum
-
Russ & Daughters at the Jewish Museum – Stylish café serving up iconic Jewish deli fare like bagels and lox, matzo ball soup, and knishes.
-
Sarabeth’s East – Known for brunch, baked goods, and a polished setting.
-
Bluestone Lane – Aussie-style café for avocado toast, flat whites, and light bites.
-
Candle Café – Vegan and vegetarian menu with a zen vibe, perfect for a quiet lunch.
Where Are The Best Photo Opportunities?
At the Jewish Museum, you’ll want to snap the exterior of the Warburg Mansion and the grand interior staircase. Exhibitions often include beautiful modern art and intricate ceremonial objects. At the NYHS, you’ll find cool photo ops near the Center for Women’s History and in the DiMenna space. Both also have well-designed entrances for that “I was here” shot.
We’re Finished And Thirsty – Is There A Decent Bar In The Area?
We’re Finished And Thirsty – Is There A Decent Bar In The Area?
Near New York Historical Society
-
Tavern On The Green – Classic NYC spot in Central Park with cocktails and patio seating.
-
The Dead Poet – A cozy literary-themed bar with craft beer and clever cocktails.
-
George Keeley’s – Laid-back neighborhood pub with sports on the screen and good happy hour deals.
Near The Jewish Museum
-
The Penrose – Trendy yet casual spot with creative cocktails and a solid menu of bar snacks.
-
The Guthrie Inn – A chill, hidden gem with low lighting and expertly mixed drinks.
Any Other Good Stuff Nearby?
Near New-York Historical Society
-
American Museum of Natural History – Just steps away and perfect for families.
-
Central Park – Take a walk or relax at the nearby Diana Ross Playground or Shakespeare Garden.
-
Lincoln Center – Head south for evening performances and world-class culture.
Near The Jewish Museum
-
The Guggenheim Museum – Right down the street with its iconic spiral architecture.
-
Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum – A playful and stylish stop for lovers of design and tech.
-
Central Park Conservatory Garden – A peaceful, formal garden space near 105th Street with fountains and floral paths.
Whether you’re after sweeping stories of American democracy or the nuanced richness of Jewish identity and creativity, both the New-York Historical Society and The Jewish Museum deliver exceptional experiences. With Go City®, you can visit either (or both!) while saving money and making the most of your time in the city. Dive into the details, reflect on the past, and enjoy a meaningful day of exploration in two of New York’s most inspiring institutions.
Ready to ramp up your New York experience? Discover Free Experiences Just Steps From The Statue Of Liberty and Things to do Near Top of the Rock
Step up your sightseeing with Go City®.
We make it easy to explore the best a city has to offer. We’re talking top attractions, hidden gems and local tours, all for one low price. Plus you'll enjoy guaranteed savings, compared to buying individual attraction tickets.
See more, do more, and experience more with Go City® - just choose a pass to get started!
This article was generated with the help of AI to provide accurate and up-to-date information. The Go City team has reviewed and curated the content to ensure it meets our quality standards for accuracy and relevance.
